Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Posts Tagged ‘closed records’

Advocacy on behalf of restoring civil rights to allow adoptees access to their original birth certificates (OBCs) has always been based on principles that are arbitrary in nature and globally the pendulum has traditionally swung to the side that promotes absolutes rather than alternative types of reform that can implement change on a more conditional basis.  At large, the controversy at hand in the adoptee rights community is equal rights for all adoptees or nothing at all vs. incremental change. I concede that both perspectives have powerful supporting reasons that could be subject for debate for eons of time.

Regardless of your personal position there is a disaster in the making in Texas which will no doubt effect the adoptee/adoption community. According to ABC News Texas Republicans are trying their hardest to pass a Bill into law with respect to making abortion rights more strict by closing 42 abortion clinics leaving only five clinics for a state that is 773 miles wide and 790 miles long with a population of 26 million people* (that’s a lot of ppl).  *http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/wireStory/texas-senate-set-filibuster-finale-abortion-19479430#.UcryZ9ggvTq

For purposes of this blog this is not an issue regarding abortion as there are other areas connected to issues of identity falling to the wayside such as anonymous sperm donation and surrogate mothers. This is an issue regarding adoption reform, or maybe better stated, Identity Reform. In the event this Bill passes and becomes law, it’s fairly safe to presume adoption rates will most certainly increase. The issue that will spur with this potential law is that Texas is a closed records state for adoptees and unfortunately there doesn’t seem to be too much hope that this will change for Texas adoptees in the foreseeable future.

As Adoptee Right’s Advocates at what point do we stop the bleeding and apply a tourniquet? At what point do we stop taking on more hostages in this civil rights battle? Is the current perspective, the larger the crowd the more voices we’ll gain? When do advocates draw the line and make the clear distinction between advocacy for equal civil rights and policy reform? At what point do we liberate the future generations from this burden? Or, even if change comes in the fashion where future born adoptees have access to their OBCs, and the closed record era remains closed, will the future adoptees truly be liberated? Or, Is this a civil rights issue that the torch should in fact be passed on to future generations of adoptees? And, are adoptees of this generation prepared to deal with not having access to their OBCs before we die of even old age?

At the very least I have to acknowledge that as an institution adoption in the United States does not appear to be going anywhere any time soon. Personally, I would utilize this acknowledgement and do everything I can to effect change in policy reform because it makes sense to stop the run-away train known as the closed record era.  If it were up to me I would prefer that the future generations know that this generation did everything in our power to do everything we could humanly possible do to unseal records, and not just for our generation. The need for advocacy for civil rights is not linear in scope, it is not one size fits all, it is in fact a multi-generational issue that spans from adoptees who are grandparents to those who are not born yet. Just the same, the issue of Rights also spans, from Human Rights to Policy Reform. And as sure as elder adoptees will die of old age and natural causes without their OBC or meeting their natural mother, or knowing siblings, adoptee advocates of today will do the same.

I suppose the true question is, as society continues to evolve its focus on the bottom line for results and with advocates by virtue placing all their eggs in the Equal Access for All Adoptees or Nothing at All basket, how do we want adoptees in the future generations to reflect upon this generation of adoptee advocates with our hyper-focus on the here and now?  Who knows, maybe they will say, “Wow, that was a great start.”

–JG

 

 

 

Advertisements

Read Full Post »